Skip to content
The Ubyssey

culture / Lifestyle

Hunting for the best haunted house

What makes one scare better than another? Where is the line between fear and fun? And who in this city rides that line best?

The orange-lit fairground at Playland.
Parker Douglas / The Ubyssey

The first haunted house I ever visited was in a small county fair, somewhere in Ontario, when I was much too young to really know what was going on. They called it “The Black Hole” and it was just about the most terrifying thing my six-year-old self had ever experienced. Picture this: you step out from the autumn daylight and into a dark room. Turn right and you’re on a little metal bridge crossing through a spinning tunnel of spiralling paint and little sparkling lights. It feels like walking through a Dutch angle — the world tilts around you as you stumble forward. At the other end of the tunnel, an old scarecrow sits in a plastic folding chair and — just as you’re about to emerge back into the sun — it jumps up and goes “boo!”

This was a real test of mettle. As a kid, I was easily scared, and despite some morbid curiosity, I would avoid anything spooky — horror movies, haunted houses, all of it. But coming out of "The Black Hole," I felt I had accomplished something huge. In a matter of minutes, I faced my fears and pulled through to the other end. I got to be brave.

Jump ahead 15 or so years, and I've become a horror fanatic. I have seen dozens, if not hundreds, of horror films, and my butt is seated in theatres for most of the big releases. I even study horror fiction and film at the graduate level. But there's an itch that films can't scratch. That immersion, that overcoming. To live in a horror movie and come out the other end is a high only a haunted house can provide.

Giant statue of clown in hay.

At the fairgrounds of Playland's Fright Nights.

Parker Douglas / The Ubyssey

Over the past few years, I have been chased by chainsaw-wielding clowns, squeezed through tight hallways under maddening strobe light, held at prop-knifepoint, blindfolded by a fabric hood, and grabbed, pushed, and tossed through labyrinths of plywood and neon paint. I have subjected myself, willingly and enthusiastically, to the recreational terror industry.

I'm not alone. There is a good chance that if you’re reading this, you're among the many young people who make an annual pilgrimage into the depths of a haunted house.

Why do so many of us flock to haunted attractions every Halloween? What makes one scare better than another? Where is the line between fear and fun? And who in this city rides that line best?

To answer these questions, I visited three prominent haunt events in Vancouver and the Lower Mainland: Playland’s Fright Nights in Vancouver, Cougar Creek’s House of Horrors in Surrey, and Maan Farms’ Halloween Fright Festival in Abbotsford. All three are built upon the same foundations of twisting mazes, scare actors, fog machines, and strobe lights, but each offers their own insights into the world of recreational terror.

Of the three events I attended this year, Playland’s Fright Nights is the one I have visited the most in the past. It is an easy entry point for first-time hauntgoers. The event features seven individual haunted houses — the most out of the three locations. Each haunt is its own freestanding maze of terror designed around classic horror tropes like killer clowns or haunted dolls. Guests line up outside a haunt of their choice, wander through its winding hallways and gruesome sets, and re-emerge into the park. This makes the experience customizable, especially when guests have the opportunity to break up their night with Playland’s array of rides and games. The price — $39–$69 depending on the night — was not the cheapest on our list, but is far from the three-figure financial commitment that more “extreme” haunts charge.

It's also a great place for first-time scare actors. Douglas College student Connor Froese was stationed in Playland's “Darkness” haunt in 2022 and gave me some insight from the other side of the mask. While not himself a student at the time, Froese notes many of his fellow scare actors were attending university during their tenure at Playland. Also in their midst were many aspiring actors who worked Fright Nights as a seasonal gig.

Froese says that Playland was particularly mindful of safety, which is critical for this job. It’s easy to forget when you walk through a haunted house — being terrorized by "monsters" in silicone masks and monster suits — that the actors are in a far more vulnerable position than the guests. Froese explained that some guests, often teenagers showing off, will become aggressive during the haunt. To address this, scare actors are equipped with a panic button in their section to keep them safe, and in Froese’s experience, this has come in handy at least once or twice for just about every actor.

So why put yourself in harm’s way for a gig like this? Froese says it’s gratifying in the same way that scaring one of your friends is. Except in this case, there's no chance of giving someone an unwanted scare. "They've signed up for this, so you really get to let loose,” he said.

It’s not a matter of simply jumping out and screaming “boo!” Froese likens scare acting to stand-up comedy; the actor must play with tension and payoff to get a big reaction. Even when the audience can see an obvious punchline — or in this case, a jumpscare — coming their way, a good actor will let that tension build until the scare lands, no matter how much the guests expect it. “It has a lot more sort of creativity and verve to it than people might think,” Froese said.

The highlight of our night at Playland was the “Keepers Doll Factory.” While most houses have a backstory you can track down online if you’re dedicated enough, Keepers’ narrative is explicitly communicated to guests walking through the attraction. The facade is detailed with rust and piping — some industrial nightmare out of Silent Hill — and plastered to the wall is a large newspaper headline, teasing the story within.

Upon entering the house, we were ushered into a small room decorated to look like an elevator, complete with a screen to emulate a window into the elevator shaft. When the “elevator” started moving, the floor beneath us shifted and bounced. It set us off balance and eventually simulated an elevator crash. Suddenly, the door opposite us slid open and in popped a living doll with a well-timed scare.

A sign labeling the entrance to a haunted house.

Outside Keepers Doll Factory.

Parker Douglas / The Ubyssey

The rest of the house delivered on its twisted dollhouse theming. The sets were all styled as a filthy industrial complex overtaken by living dolls putting on a gruesome show just for you. Inanimate dolls and mannequins dotted the maze as red herrings for scare actors to blend in with. You don't know which doll is going to move — if any — so it's impossible to properly brace for the scare. When an actor does finally lunge out from the crowd, there's nothing to do but scream. It’s a great example of how attention to theming and shrewd design choices carried this haunted house without a need for high-budget effects and set pieces.

Compare this to the least compelling house at the event, "Materia Medica." While the name of the attraction would lead one to assume a hospital or mental asylum theme, according to the Fright Nights website, it is, in fact, themed to be a military base. This never came across, as the maze wound its way through unclear and often bland set pieces.

At one point, guests must squeeze between a pair of inflated walls, like being trapped between two pitch-black bouncy castles. While this effect appears in other haunts as well, here it stands out as particularly alien to the theming. What does this have to do with to do with a military base? Or a hospital? Or asylum?

The animatronic set piece of a car bashing through the wall is a similarly impressive feature but ultimately out of place. Many rooms felt empty. There was one winding hallway devoid of any actors or sets, instead opting to scare guests with lengths of clearly visible fishing wire in your path. It was not effective and the absence of clear theming in the house makes it quickly forgettable.

Fortunately for Fright Nights, this was one dud of a house out of seven. Not every event can claim such a ratio.

Far and away, the best part about Playland’s Fright Nights is the atmosphere. There is a constant energy that you only get from being at an amusement park. Roller coasters and drop towers soar overhead and actors roam the park for interactive one-on-one scares — the event feels like a big Halloween party. It’s not always the scariest or the most intensely detailed haunt, but it's consistently fun. For anyone who has never been to a haunted house before, there is nowhere better in the Lower Mainland to start.

Cougar Creek offered a far more intense and intimate experience than Playland in terms of house design and event organization. One thing I noted was how — especially on a night with such short lines as when we went — Playland moved at a comfortable pace as we wandered easily from mazes to roller coasters to food and drink stands. There was time for breaks and room to breathe. Cougar Creek offers no such respite — you are here to get scared, and once they’ve caught you in their grasp, they won't let you go.

Cougar Creek features five themed mazes that feed into each other in one long, linear experience. You get a room between each attraction to catch your breath before the next nightmare begins. This is not to say you can’t leave the house once you enter, but you do so at a price: above the entrance to the maze, the lighted number on the “chicken counter” display goes up by one.

I cannot stress enough how effective the counter was in establishing the atmosphere for Cougar Creek. The haunt staff intentionally spaced out groups so everyone's experience in the attraction was isolated and personal. Because of this spacing — and because Cougar Creek is essentially one long maze rather than separate haunts — the lineup can get long. Waiting in the holding area, hearing the screams of guests as they creep through the house, the chicken counter taunts you. Can you survive the gauntlet? Do you have the guts? Or are you gonna chicken out?

Waiting in line at Cougar Creek was, unlike at other events, a highlight of the experience. The queue weaved back and forth before a stage upon which Dandy (of the Dead), a drag performer some may know from hosting events at the Rio Theatre, danced and sang along to tunes like “I Want Candy” and “Time Warp” from The Rocky Horror Picture Show. Dandy teased at one point early in the show that their presence was itself a form of psychological horror, soothing and disarming guests so they may be more susceptible to the scares within.

A performer sings on a stage

Cougar Creek's performers kept the line alive between houses.

Abbie Chung / The Ubyssey

And boy, did it work. The actors at Cougar Creek are far more interactive than the ones stationed in Playland. You will be stalked by the same character from room to room, until suddenly they appear in front of you, having taken some secret path hidden in the walls.

The haunt starts with "Abomination," a backwoods-themed house drawing from films like The Texas Chainsaw Massacre. In what was one of the most memorable moments of the night, I was confronted by an actor dressed in homage to Buffalo Bill from Silence of the Lambs. They gestured for me to sit in an armchair and, without touching me, held me in place with a prop knife inches away from my face. When they gestured for me to go, I slowly stood up, only for them to lunge at me again, spooking me right back into the chair. It is a testament to Cougar Creek's quality that the actors are able to control a scene and instill such fear in guests without laying a finger on them.

The houses were, with the exception of one, detailed with so much precision it caused me to gag. Set pieces of gore litter just about every house, but especially the first three: "Abomination," "New Year's Evil," and "Echoes of Abbath." Animatronic decapitations and rotting corpses abounded and were presented at such breakneck speed from room to room you hardly had a chance to process the horrors you'd seen. Alex Koronczay, a friend who joined myself and videographer Abbie Chung at Cougar Creek, remarked how I’d come out looking green. 

Calling Cougar Creek a “maze” is particularly fitting too — its narrow winding halls are especially disorienting when paired with dangling chains and hanging threads. At one point in the Echoes of Abbath house, there is a water wheel spinning outside of a window and what looks to be another hallway passing parallel to ours. I assumed this was just a facade until after the following house, "AstroParasitix," we found ourselves back in Echoes of Abbath and on the other end of the water wheel. My head was spinning.

Cougar Creek, as much as I have sung its praises, is not without its faults. The final house, "Sinneraria," is such a remarkable downturn in detail from the previous four that I thought we’d accidentally wandered into a backstage area. The walls were all inflatable, meant to evoke a military quarantine as zombies lunge out from dark corners. There were no set pieces in here and less standout actor interactions than what had come before. With the intensity of the previous houses, this was a bit of an underwhelming note to end on, though not so disappointing as to have diminished the rest of the event. I was still giddy as we broke through that last tent flap and into the cold night air.

As much as I enjoyed the easy pace of an event like Playland’s Fright Nights, the gauntlet-style setup of Cougar Creek undeniably heightened the intensity. There is a moment of incredible pride and bliss as you find yourself back at the entrance and know that the chicken counter won’t be going up on your account.

Scott Pasternak, the creative director of Cougar Creek’s House of Horrors, told me about what goes into designing a haunt like this. Pasternak has a deep love for and extensive knowledge of horror movies, which is reflected in references all throughout the attraction. He is also a veteran in the business, with close to 20 years of experience designing attractions like House of Horrors.

Designing a house starts with the basics: safety standards and fire codes. Once that "boring part" is out of the way, Pasternak starts thinking up a theme for the house. From there, it's a process of making that theme work logistically, laying out the twists and turns of the haunt to make the most of the space available and provide passages for scare actors to disappear and reappear. A lot of effort goes into detailing the sets and lighting, and creating an atmosphere beyond merely the shock of jumpscares.

When the haunt is running, and when Pasternak isn’t fixing blown out lights or pulled wires, he and his team get to monitor the scares from a 64-camera display in a central office. As fun as it is to scare and be scared, there’s also a simple joy in watching it all unfold.

Maan Farms boasts the title of “The Scariest Corn Maze in Canada” across their marketing. It was the event I was the most nervous for, particularly because it was the only one of the three which involved full contact with the scare actors. Friends (and even professors) told me horror stories about how terrifying this experience was.

All the way out in Abbotsford, the drive was daunting. Google Maps — also apparently haunted — routed us through the backroads of Langley for extra spooky ambience. I braced myself for true terror.

Did Maan Farms deliver? Not entirely, I’m sad to say.

You're told to attend each of the four attractions in a particular order — likely to evenly distribute the crowd. Because of that, we started at the newest haunt, “Badlands.” The theme here was extreme weather. Instead of any highly themed sets, you walk through a series of chambers with sensory effects that simulate these conditions.

There was a maze with the heat cranked up, one with freezing air conditioning, a rain tunnel (that made me glad I ditched my paper notebook), and a long corridor blasted with high-power fans. Scare actors jumped out of dark corners and spooked us with loud noises. But the theming of Badlands was so vague and abstract that I was never immersed enough to be scared. The effects were well-crafted but would have better served as additions to another themed haunt than as the backbone of their own maze.

Empty space ends up being an overarching problem at Maan Farms and especially so in the “Slaughter House.” While there were a couple of great moments — an impressive giant pig animatronic lunged within inches of my face — a lot of the time was spent in empty hallways with strobe lights and a few loud noises. There were fewer actors than I’d come to expect after Cougar Creek and Playland, and the ones that were there mostly stayed at their stations without much direct guest interaction. 

The other two attractions, however, carried the experience, and it was lucky that we ended with them.

“The Way Down” takes place in total darkness. A black hood was placed over each of our heads, obscuring our vision almost completely. This is where the full contact we were promised finally came into play.

We were told to follow a guide rope at all times. As we went along, the rope's texture would change to something wet and slimy and I’d want to pull my hands away, but then I’d be lost in the dark. Actors frequently came up from behind, grabbed me, pushed me along. At one point I was pulled fully off the rope and made to dance with one of the actors. My hood was then removed and they shoved me into a corridor so dark I couldn’t see, even with the hood off. The actors sounded gleeful as they prodded and poked at me in the dark, swiping at my legs and tossing me forward. It was thrilling and unlike any haunt I’d experienced before.

The obligatory clown haunt, “3D CarnEvil,” was also full-contact, and it, too, was an absolute scream. On approaching the front door of the house, we were given 3D glasses that made the neon paint pop from the walls. The journey through the funhouse was, as such, particularly disorienting. It was hard to tell how far I was from the walls, and the paint splotches looked like they were moving. This made the scares all the more heart-stopping.

Dizzy from the dancing paint, I was unprepared for a clown to lunge out from the wall and grab me by the back of the neck, pulling me in only inches away from their face. Another clown with a vaudeville hook tugged me by the arm and flung me into the next room. It was equal parts hilarious and horrifying.

Of all the individual haunted houses across all three events, “The Way Down” and “3D CarnEvil” rank among the best. Unfortunately, it’s hard to justify the cost of admission based on these alone.

Having snagged early bird tickets for Maan Farms Fright Festival, I paid $59 for the event, which is already more expensive than any night at Cougar Creek and most nights at Playland. The regular price for the night we visited Maan Farms was $99 in advance or $114 if you bought day-of. While the two full-contact haunts were exceptionally fun and frightening, there is no way to justify the price of this experience opposite the admission costs for Cougar Creek and Playland, both less than half the price most nights.

At least we know we won’t be needing to make that long drive out again next year.

If you’re looking for the bottom line, here it is: Playland is the best experience for casual hauntgoers, while Cougar Creek stands out as the scariest and most impressive haunt of the bunch. Maan Farms, despite two excellent full-contact haunts, fails to live up to its title of “Scariest Corn Maze in Canada” in any aspect but the price tag.

Regardless of which holds the crown, there is undeniably a great deal of craft and performance that goes into their design and execution. In the Lower Mainland alone, there is a wealth of passionate designers and actors that come together to create this incredibly particular and seasonal art.

So why do we do it?

“People just love the adrenaline rush,” Pasternak said. But he also knows that guests appreciate the level of detail in these sets, props, effects, lighting, costumes, and the like. As he puts it: “I think a lot of people love to look at cool things.”

As a former scare actor, Froese insists hauntgoers give themselves over to the experience, play along, and let themselves get scared. “Being scared is like humour,” he said, “in that it doesn’t really make sense why it’s enjoyable. But it is.”

If you find your way to one of these haunts this Halloween, remember the artistry and excitement that goes into building the labyrinth around you. Take it all in with each lungful of artificial fog. Don’t forget to scream.

Apply for erasureSend a tipReport an error