opinion

Haack: Gaza controversy a result of lackluster leadership


By



With national media purporting that UBC might be funding terrorism, and is trying to one-up CSIS, you have to ask stop and ask WTF, what is wrong with us. The answer is quite simple: leadership. Something the current AMS President Bijan Ahmadian quite honestly and thoroughly lacks.

In November, the Executive deferred the decision to approve a donation to the Canadian Boat to Gaza from the SJC. Ask yourself: what decision? The SJC is well within its rights to spend money as they wish. Council can veto the SJC with a 2/3s majority, but council approval isn’t required. The only reason this came to Council was to kill the transaction.

The Executives first mistake: picking a side by deciding to intervene. If the SJC donated money to a cause students oppose, students hold them accountable. The SJC are autonomous and responsible for their actions. The AMS’ role in resource group transactions is purely administrative; reviewing the SJC’s budget and paperwork to ensure everything is in order. Deciding to intervene because its nature is not administrative, it’s political.

Their second mistake: haphazardly justifying their actions with paper-thin arguments. They say the SJC cheated their way through an AGM, and the Gaza Flotilla is a terrorist activity. Sounds like it could be true, so why not, eh? Well, for the sake of process I’ll take five minutes to see if those allegations are true. First, let’s just Google it. Better yet, let me Google that for you (http://tinyurl.com/2ejbwne) to avoid any Bijan-styled mistakes.

The Alternatives home page lists a few supporters of their “terrorist activities” with Margaret Atwood and Archbishop Desmond Tutu among them. That was two minutes of my life. I promised to spend five, so let’s Wiki Alternatives. Their funders include: the Government of Canada and the Canadian International Development Agency. I’m inclined to say the donation is legit and just move on but for some reason, a couple Executives decided to go with their gut and ethno-profile it as a terrorist activity because it involves Gaza.

Which leads us to their third mistake: making it personal. We have a President who has, on numerous occasions, voiced his personal opinion instead of that of Council’s. One who threatened to sue the AMS — an organization he apparently leads — after Council passed a motion asking him to not speak on an issue. Ask yourself, what kind of research did Bijan do to conclude they were terrorists? Was it Archbishop Tutu’s support of the project that gave it away, or the federal funding? He clearly has a personal opinion, and as he’s indicated in the past that he’s absolutely willing to bully people into getting his way, Council included.

The Canadian Boat to Gaza, a purely Canadian initiative, sponsored by Alternatives, a registered charity with funding from the federal government, but is apparently connected with terrorism. Clearly, the easiest way to get supplies for terrorist abroad is through a very public yearlong, national fundraising campaign and soliciting money from the general public. They got passed CSIS, but they better watch out for Bijan, cause he knows better than those guys.

Vote This Post DownVote This Post Up (+49 rating, 35 votes)
Loading ... Loading ...

7 Comments

  1. Pilar says:

    OSNAP! <3

  2. Yur says:

    Wow – that was surprisingly informative. Did not know Margaret Atwood, Desmond Tutu and Canadian Government were supporting it. Thanks.

    Great article.

    Also did not know about Bijan threatening to sue the AMS. He is frankly an embarrassment. I am really ready for him to get off campus.

  3. You Can Do Better says:

    Michael, you’ve written better before and think you could have been more articulate as you usually are.

    Ubyssey, copyedit your online articles, there are tons of errors in this. “They got passed CSIS,” for one.

    • AliceLang says:

      do you mean “they got past CSIS”? Isn’t passed right?

      I think it was articulate and just as fun to read as your other ones. you should consider writing more for the paper, michael.

  4. chrisanne says:

    haha great article!

  5. HindS says:

    Great analysis and one that should be a front page article of Ubyssey. Thanks for taking 5 minutes of your life to voice what many of us were shocked to read when the issue came up.

  6. WHat says:

    just attacking= this guys offers no solution whatsoever

View profile and all articles by
Bookmark the permalink. Follow any comments here with the RSS feed for this post. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

TRIUMF Lab/flickr
Geoff Lister/The Ubyssey
Geoff Lister/The Ubyssey
Kai Jacobson/The Ubyssey
Mary Kitagawa of the Greater Vancouver Japanese-Canadian Citizens Association led the push to award the honorary degrees. Photo courtesy Don Erhardt.
Geoff Lister/The Ubyssey
fboudville/Flickr
mehlam786/flickr
TRIUMF Lab/flickr
featured-doxa
Kai Jacobson/The Ubyssey
Yara De Jong/The Ubyssey
Kai Jacobson/The Ubyssey
The trail camera for Bear 71. Bill Stilwell/flickr
Big_Boys_Gone_Bananas_featured
Writers' Centre Norwich/Flickr
Geoff Lister/The Ubyssey
Courtesy of Stephen Dyrgas

Comic Bryce Warnes/The Ubyssey
Ivan Yasterbov/The Ubyssey
Geoff Lister/The Ubyssey
Courtesy of Edvard Elgudzhyan

Remembering a genocide 97 years later

Last words
Geoff Lister/The Ubyssey
Bryce's column
Last words
Geoff Lister/The Ubyssey

Yara De Jong/The Ubyssey
Geoff Lister/The Ubyssey
featured
Kai Jacobson/The Ubyssey
Geoff Lister/The Ubyssey
Indiana Joel Illustration/The Ubyssey
hea
Josh Curran/The Ubyssey
Indiana Joel Illustration/The Ubyssey

Kai Jacobson/The Ubyssey
Courtesy Rich Lam/UBC Athletics
Courtesy Jason Dormeyer/Concordia University Athletics
Andrew Firth at the bat in the NAIA West tournament in 2010. Jon Chiang/The Ubyssey
Josh Curran/The Ubyssey
Rich Lam/UBC Athletics
Indiana Joel/The Ubyssey
Geoff Lister/The Ubyssey
Courtesy CWHL Brandon Taylor

weeklyshow
Screen Shot 2012-04-13 at 2.30.26 PM

Block Party 2012

Screen Shot 2012-04-12 at 5.28.26 PM

UBC Undie Run 2012

Screen Shot 2012-04-12 at 5.24.58 PM

UBC Undie Run 2012 [Raw footage]

Screen Shot 2012-03-26 at 12.25.06 PM
Picture 2
Screen Shot 2012-03-19 at 1.01.50 PM
Screen Shot 2012-03-19 at 5.40.26 AM
wpid-Videobasketball_20120315__Geoff-Lister.jpg

Travers Final

Stories of the year

wpid-20120410__Geoff-Lister-The-Ubyssey.jpg

Undie Run 2012

Geoff Lister/The Ubyssey

Projecting at the Norm

wpid-Womens-Volleyball_20120225__Geoff-Lister.jpg
wpid-20120319__.jpg
wpid-Fred-Penner_20120313__Geoff-Lister.jpg
wpid-Vanier-Musical_20120301__Alexandra-Downing.jpg
wpid-Biomass-Plant_20120229__-2.jpg
Geoff Lister/The Ubyssey

Ubyssey Blog Network