opinion

Editorial: Granville redesign hardly matters



“If you can develop and design streets so that they are wonderful, fulfilling places to be—community building places, attractive for all people—then we will have successfully designed about one-third of the city.”

So says the Allan Jacobs quote you’ll be greeted with if you go to the homepage of the Granville Street Redesign Project, which reaches completion this month. Now that the Granville Mall has been repaved and planted with trees, right in time for the Olympics, has it transformed into a flourishing centre of community involvement and civic pride? Of course not; it’s the same old shopping and clubbing district, just a bit polished up. You’d find more community cultivating at the bottom of a yogurt container.

Granville isn’t a place to hold inclusive events, nor is it woven from a rich tapestry of people from different backgrounds. It’s woven from a collection of business interests. It’s a place with stores, both large and high-end, with a smattering of fast food joints and “Irish” pubs. It’s a place pumping house at $10 a head, where you and your bros can chase after girls with exposed thongs and tramp stamps. It’s a place where medium-scale plays concerts are performed. But most importantly, it’s a place where you break out your wallet and spend big bucks.

Not everything about the redesign is bad. It’s great news that they tried to retool the street as pedestrian-oriented; very few use cars downtown anymore. But when the $20 million redesign facelift began, the city wasn’t thinking about civic pride or an inclusive community. There was a run-down entertainment district filled with porn shops, and they thought they could raise property values. The porn shops are still there, god bless them, but districts that actually promote community in Vancouver don’t mean a thing to the city. If you want community, build it yourself. It’s at best unnoticed and at worst opposed by the city. 

As if City Hall ever thought we’d all join hands and start singing along Granville once it had some trees and restricted motor traffic.

Vote This Post DownVote This Post Up (No Ratings Yet)
Loading ... Loading ...

Post a Comment

This is a moderated comment board. Comments that appear on ubyssey.ca are not the opinions of The Ubyssey, but only of the comment writer. We reserve the right to delete any posts which contain personal attacks, offensive language or unsubstantiated allegations.

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*
View profile and all articles by none
Bookmark the permalink. Follow any comments here with the RSS feed for this post. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

Courtesy of UBC Public Affairs

New Pharmacy building slated for 2012 opening

Maria Kari

Brendan Albano/The Ubyssey

The “Protector of Forests” has arrived

Maria Kari

Geoff Lister/The Ubyssey

Student unemployment soars to 20%

Maria Kari

Arts students can take calculus too! Geoff Lister/The Ubyssey

Credit/D/Fail to be implemented at UBC

Maria Kari

spine

Underage on the town

Kristy Dindorf

Comic courtesy Kate Beaton/Hark! A Vagrant

Hysterically inaccurate

Miranda Martini

Mapping a new Vancouver. COURTESY JERM IX/FLICKR

The writing on the wall

Grace Mcrae-Okine

Attendees at the 2009 Victoria Fringe Festival

Tough summer for BC Arts

Jonny Wakefield

tofino_bus_mega
Courtesy of Carlosvans619/Photobucket

Dead tired over lack of zombie plan

Goh Iromoto/The Ubyssey

G20 riot coverage missed the real point

Cartoon by Maria Cirstea/The Ubyssey

Koerner’s changes, and we don’t like it

Condos

Talkin’ CCP transparency blues

OknaganPanoramic

UBC Okanagan | Our cousins to the east

Trevor Record

UBCOcampus

UBC Okanagan | No school-hopping at UBC

Trevor Record

Construction

UBC Okanagan | Did UBC-O begin as a ‘hostile takeover?

Justin McElroy

Trevor

UBC Okanagan | A university divided cannot stand

Trevor Record

UBC Skiing Club file photo

Varsity teams you can join with no experience

Ian Turner

Football Training Camp

Football Training Camp Update

Ian Turner

Stephanie Warren Illustration

Men’s Volleyball Team Leaving for Korea

Ian Turner

Football

UBC Football Training Camp Starts Saturday

Ian Turner

Ubyssey Blog Network

Coming Soon!
Coming Soon!